Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0
The U.S. immigration court system plays a critical role in upholding due process and ensuring fair hearings for individuals facing deportation. However, since January 20, 2025, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has implemented significant changes that challenge the structural integrity of these courts. This page aims to provide up-to-date information on the policy and legal shifts affecting the U.S. immigration court system.
Latest Updates
Updates from EOIR
Browse the Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0 collection
BIA Finds Respondent Did Not Prove That State Court Vacated His Conviction Due to Defect in His Criminal Proceedings
The BIA held that, where the state court order granting the respondent’s motion to vacate did not indicate the reason for the vacatur, the respondent did not prove that the court vacated the conviction due to a defect in his criminal proceedings. Matter of Azrag, 28 I&N Dec. 784 (BIA 2024)
CA2 Upholds Asylum Denial Where Petitioner Had Safely Relocated Twice in India
The court upheld BIA’s conclusion that the government had rebutted the presumption of future persecution by showing that petitioner could safely relocate within India, finding petitioner’s argument that he had been living in hiding unpersuasive. (Bhagtana v. Garland, 12/5/23, amended 2/22/24)
Resources on Case Challenging Interim Final Rule on Asylum Claims at the Southern Border
The Ninth Circuit granted the parties’ Joint Motion to Place Appeal in Abeyance pending settlement negotiations in this case and a related case, M.A. v. Mayorkas. (East Bay Sanctuary Covenant, et al. v. Biden, et al., 2/21/24)
Project 2025: Unveiling the far right’s plan to demolish immigration in a second Trump term
The Niskanen Center provides key takeaways from the Heritage Foundations Project 2025 policy playbook.
CA5 Holds That Petitioner Convicted in Texas for Possessing a Synthetic Cannabinoid Is Removable under INA §237(a)(2)(B)(i)
The court upheld the BIA’s conclusion that the petitioner failed to show there was a “realistic probability” that Texas would use the state statute he was convicted under to prosecute the possession of drugs that are not criminalized under federal law. (Alejos-Perez v. Garland, 2/16/24)
Practice Alert: DOJ’s $1.2 Million Settlement with IJ Scott D. Laurent’s Former Staff
AILA provides a practice alert after DOJ announced a $1.2 million settlement to a former staff assistant of immigration judge Scott D. Laurent, of the Los Angeles Immigration Court. As of the date of this alert, the IJ remains listed as a current judge.
White House Issues Memo on Deferred Enforced Departure for Certain Palestinians
President Biden issued a determination on 2/14/24 announcing that the United States will defer for 18 months the removal of any Palestinian subject to the conditions and exceptions provided. (89 FR 12743, 2/20/24)
CA9 Holds That Petitioner’s Conviction for Armed Robbery in Arizona Was Categorically an Aggravated Felony
The court found that a conviction for armed robbery in violation of Arizona Revised Statutes §13-1904(A), for which the term of imprisonment imposed is at least one year, is categorically an aggravated felony theft offense giving rise to removability. (Guzman-Maldonado v. Garland, 2/14/24)
CA3 Finds BIA and IJ Ignored Evidence Favorable to Somali Petitioner Regarding His CAT Claim
The court concluded that, in deciding the petitioner’s Convention Against Torture (CAT) claim, the BIA failed to consider evidence favorable to petitioner concerning whether the government of Somalia would acquiesce in his torture, and thus remanded to the BIA. (Herrow v. Att’y Gen., 2/13/24)
USCIS Provides Guidance on Processing Form I-589 After Removal Proceedings are Dismissed or Terminated
USCIS provides an updated flow chart on how it processes Form I-589 after removal proceedings are dismissed or terminated.
EOIR to Transition to DOJ Login
EOIR announced new procedures for accessing the ECAS Case Portal. All users will need to take action to move from User Login IDs to a DOJ Login ID. EOIR developed detailed instructions for this phased transition and will notify users by email when to activate their new DOJ Login ID.
Practice Pointer: Top 10 Things You Need to Know about the USCIS Fee Rule
AILA provides this practice resource to alert members to the most important aspects of the new fee rule so that you may better understand the impact of the new fee schedule on your clients’ cases.
BIA Says That IJ Ordinarily Cannot Review Merits of Petition to Remove Conditions on Residence Withdrawn Prior to Adjudication
The BIA held that when a petition to remove the conditions on residence is withdrawn before USCIS prior to adjudication, the IJ ordinarily cannot review the merits of that petition in removal proceedings. Matter of Bernardo, 28 I&N Dec. 781 (BIA 2024)
CA11 Holds That Petitioner Would Not Derive Citizenship under Cured Version of INA §321(a)(3)
The court held that while the petitioner had Article III standing to make his constitutional challenges, he was not entitled to the remedy he sought because he would not derive citizenship from his father even under a cured version of INA §321(a)(3). (Lodge v. Att’y Gen., 1/26/24, amended 2/7/24)
CA9 Says It Lacks Jurisdiction to Review Denial of Petitioner’s Continuance and Motion to Remand Under INA §242(a)(2)(B)(i)
Applying INA §242(a)(2)(B)(i) as interpreted by the U.S. Supreme Court in Patel v. Garland, the court held that it lacked jurisdiction to review the denial of the petitioner’s continuance and motion to remand. (Figueroa Ochoa v. Garland, 6/20/23, amended 2/6/24)
Policy Brief: AILA Analysis of the Border and Immigration Provisions of the “Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2024”
With unprecedented levels of global migration and an outdated U.S. immigration system pushing more migrants to the southern border, solutions are urgently needed. The Senate’s emergency spending bill includes the most extensive border funding and security measures proposed in decades, perhaps ever.
Practice Alert: Latest Information on the Juvenile Dockets
AILA provides takeaways from ICE’s stakeholder meeting on January 24, 2024, with information regarding the implementation and expansion of specialized juvenile dockets.
AILA Executive Director Responds to Release of Bipartisan Senate Bill
AILA Executive Director Ben Johnson responded to the newly released bill text from the bipartisan group of Senators negotiating the “Emergency National Security Supplemental Appropriations Act, 2024.”
CA4 Says Petitioner’s Hearing Was Not Fundamentally Unfair Despite IJ’s Erroneous Admission of Form I-9
The court held that the BIA and IJ did not err in finding that the petitioner was required to establish her admissibility “clearly and beyond doubt,” and rejected the petitioner’s contention that her evidentiary hearing was fundamentally unfair. (Santana v. Garland, 2/2/24)
BIA Says DHS Cannot Remedy NTA Lacking Date and Time of Hearing by Filing Form I-261
The BIA held that DHS cannot remedy a Notice to Appear (NTA) that lacks the date and time of the initial hearing before the IJ by filing a Form I-261, because that remedy is contrary to 8 CFR §1003.30 and Niz-Chavez v. Garland. Matter of Aguilar Hernandez, 28 I&N Dec. 774 (BIA 2024)
USCIS Seeks Feedback to Help Shape the USCIS Customer Experience for Appointment Requests
You can now use the USCIS website to request an in-person appointment at a field office for assistance with emergency advanced paroles, Immigration Judge grants, and ADIT stamps. USCIS seeks feedback from both applicants and legal representatives on this new process. Responses due by 2/8/24.
CA4 Holds That IJs May Make Partial or Mixed Adverse Credibility Determination If Supported by Substantial Evidence
The court found that the IJ properly made a mixed finding about credibility, and that the BIA did not err in affirming the IJ’s determination that petitioners failed to show a nexus between past or feared future harm and any familial relationship. (Ayala-Osegueda, et al. v. Garland, 2/1/24)
CA8 Remands Where BIA Failed to Provide Reasoned Explanation for Its Application of Motion-to-Reopen Standard
The court held that the IJ failed to reference the petitioner’s motion to reopen or the standard for considering it, and that the BIA failed to adequately explain its application of the motion-to-reopen standard when it affirmed the IJ’s decision. (Davis v. Garland, 2/1/24)
ICE ERO Provides Information on Beta Testing of eFile for Legal Representations
ICE announced the national launch of a new online platform, called ERO eFile, that will allow for the electronic filing of Form G-28. ICE provides a quick reference guide to eFile.
Final Rule Adjusting the USCIS Fee Schedule
Final rule adjusting the USCIS fee schedule. The final rule will be effective 4/1/24. Any benefit request postmarked on or after 4/1/24 must be accompanied with the fees established by this final rule. (89 FR 6194, 1/31/24)
USCIS Provides Summary of Its Final Rule to Adjust Certain Immigration and Naturalization Fees
USCIS provided a summary of its final rule, including information on the new fee schedule, the asylum program fee for employment-based petitions, naturalization fee changes, international adoption validity period changes, and more.
AILA Responds to New Biden Administration Rules on Fees and H-1B Registration Process
AILA responded to the advance copies shared publicly by the Biden Administration regarding U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) fees and a revised H-1B visa registration process with insights from President Farshad Owji and Dir of Gov’t Relations Shev Dalal-Dheini.
CA8 Upholds Asylum Denial as to Guatemalan Petitioner Who Received Threats Due to Father’s Unpaid Debt
The court held that the petitioner neither demonstrated that he suffered past persecution on account of a protected factor, nor offered credible, specific evidence that a reasonable person in his position would fear persecution if he returned to Guatemala. (Gaspar-Felipe v. Garland, 1/30/24)
CA4 Upholds Asylum Denial to Salvadoran Petitioner Who Failed to Show Nexus Between His Extortion and Family Membership
The court held that the IJ and BIA did not err in determining that the Salvadoran petitioner had failed to establish nexus between his claimed social group and his extortion by the MS-13 gang, and thus upheld the denial of asylum and withholding of removal. (Lopez-Benitez v. Garland, 1/30/24)
BIA Finds New Evidence Showed Respondent Was Detained Pursuant to INA §236(a) and Was Thus Entitled to Bond Hearing
Unpublished BIA decision holds that the respondent who claimed fear of persecution and who had not received a credible fear interview was entitled to a bond hearing pursuant to INA §236 based on new evidence indicating that she was in removal proceedings under INA §240. (Matter of –, 1/30/24)
Is Chevron Dead? Thoughts after Oral Arguments in Relentless, Inc. and Loper Bright Enterprises
Brian Green and Stephen Yale-Loehr describe the recent oral arguments in two SCOTUS cases which could dramatically affect federal agency review; it is yet unclear whether the decisions will hurt or help immigrants when challenging ambiguous agency decisions or interpretations.
AILA Advocacy Toolkit for Congressional Border Deal
AILA provides members with a summary of border supplemental funding proposals that would trade funding for Ukraine and other allies for dramatic changes to U.S. asylum and detention laws. This toolkit includes Senate office contact information, template emails, and a template call script.
CA1 Remands Asylum Claim of Salvadoran Petitioner Who Was Threatened by Cattle Thieves and Beaten by Police
The court vacated the agency’s denial of asylum, withholding of removal, and Convention Against Torture (CAT) relief as to petitioner, who had been threatened by cattle thieves who murdered his father and who had been beaten by the police in El Salvador. (Pineda-Maldonado v. Garland, 1/24/24)
A Bridge We Can All Cross
AILA members César Magaña Linares and Raquel Fernández—a Salvadoran Dreamer with TPS and a second generation Venezuelan American—call for intra-immigrant solidarity.
CA6 Upholds Asylum Denial After Finding That Petitioner Failed to Show State-Sanctioned Persecution
The court upheld the BIA’s determination that the petitioner, who alleged that he had been persecuted in Ghana on account of his political opinions and party membership, failed to establish state action and was thus ineligible for asylum or withholding of removal. (Owusu v. Garland, 1/24/24)
CA8 Finds BIA Did Not Contradict IJ’s Findings in Denying Special Rule Cancellation of Removal
On remand from the Supreme Court, the court held that the BIA permissibly weighed differently the evidence of harm that petitioner caused to his ex-girlfriend and her daughter without impermissibly finding facts or disregarding the IJ’s factual findings. (Mencia-Medina v. Garland, 1/23/24)
EOIR to Open Concord Immigration Court
EOIR announced it will open a new immigration court in Concord, California, on February 12, 2024, expanding its presence in Northern California. The Concord Immigration Court will have 21 immigration judges.
SCOTUS Hears Oral Arguments on Notice Requirements (Again)
In this blog post, AILA Policy and Practice Counsel Manolasya Perepa describes the recent SCOTUS consolidated oral arguments in Campos-Chavez v. Garland and Garland v. Singh and notes that “issues of improper notice pervade multiple aspects of the immigration system.“
Practice Alert: Access to Counsel in ICE Detention
This practice alert serves to update AILA members on the recent expansion of the Virtual Attorney Visitation (VAV) program, to share resources for communicating with detained clients, and how to escalate access to counsel issues with ICE.
CA5 Remands Asylum Claim Where BIA Failed to Consider Possible Application of TVPRA to Petitioner’s Case
The court held that the BIA erred in denying petitioner’s motion to reopen without resolving whether the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act (TVPRA), which would invalidate the existing removal order, applied to the petitioner’s case. (Velasquez-Castillo v. Garland, 1/17/24)
Practice Pointer: BIA Addresses the “Unable or Unwilling” Standard in Matter of C-G-T-
AILA’s Asylum and Refugee Committee provides a practice pointer on Matter of C-G-T-, a 2023 BIA precedent decision in which the BIA reiterated the “unable or unwilling” standard as the correct legal standard for demonstrating eligibility for asylum.
ICE Announces Updated Policy for Body-Worn Cameras
ICE announced updated guidance for its law enforcement personnel, providing standards for the use of body worn cameras (BWCs). The policy calls for the use of BWCs in all aspects of ICE enforcement activities conducted by ICE personnel.
ICE Agrees to Post Its Bond Processing Policies Online in FOIA Lawsuit Settlement
A federal district court in California approved a settlement in which ICE agreed to post its bond processing policies online to settle a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit filed by bond-funding groups in December 2022. (National Bail Fund Network, et al. v. ICE, et al., 1/11/24)
No Fault/Technical Reasons: A Chronicle of Misfeasance Exposed
AILA Law Journal author Martin Robles-Avila highlights how a flawed rulemaking process has affected Nonimmigrant Status breaches and a quandary business immigration practitioners often find themselves in determining whether a client is eligible for adjustment of status.
FOIA Behind the Scenes – How USCIS and DOS Process Immigration-Related Requests
AILA member Alexandra Zaretsky describes how the International Refugee Assistance Project decided to find out how USCIS and the State Department process FOIA requests by filing a “meta-FOIA“ which unearthed some questionable agency policies of potential interest to others.
EOIR Announces 2024 Model Hearing Program
EOIR will continue its Model Hearing Program and host a series of events nationwide to provide substantive law and practical training on human trafficking, juveniles, adjustment of status, and special immigrant juvenile status. Notice includes in-person and hybrid events for January 2024.
Michigan Chapter: ICE ERO Contact List (1/9/24)
ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) Detroit contact list as of 1/9/24 – detained and non-detained.
Practice Alert: ICE Online Portal Stakeholder Engagement Notes
AILA’s National ICE Liaison Committee provides notes from a stakeholder engagement on ICE’s new Online Portal held on December 7, 2023.
2023 ICE Annual Report: Key Takeaways
ICE released the agency’s FY2023 annual report. The lengthy report summarized the agency’s primary focus areas and provided an appendix containing a summary of ICE removals by country of citizenship. AILA provides a summary of key takeaways for OPLA, ERO, and HSI.
Department of the Treasury Notice on Interest Rate for Immigration Bonds
Department of the Treasury notice that for the period beginning 1/1/24 and ending 3/31/24, the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Immigration Bond interest rate is 3 per centum per annum. (89 FR 986, 1/8/24)