Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0
The U.S. immigration court system plays a critical role in upholding due process and ensuring fair hearings for individuals facing deportation. However, since January 20, 2025, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has implemented significant changes that challenge the structural integrity of these courts. This page aims to provide up-to-date information on the policy and legal shifts affecting the U.S. immigration court system.
Latest Updates
Updates from EOIR
Browse the Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0 collection
EOIR to Post Final Rule on Appellate Procedures for the Board of Immigration Appeals
EOIR will issue a final rule on 11/17/26 on Appellate Procedures for the Board of Immigration Appeals. The final rule amends the 2/6/26 interim final rule, which shortened the appeal deadline from 30 to 10 days and made reviewing cases on the merits discretionary. An advance copy is available.
Think Immigration: Credibility Begins Before the Hearing–Why Immigration Psychological Evaluations Must Be More Record-Aware
In this blog post, AILA Law Journal author Dr. Nilda Perez shares a bit more on the topic of her law journal article, explaining how "individualized, evidence-aware, and clinically disciplined" psychological evaluations can help immigration practitioners build a more accurate and complete record.
Client Flyer: Protecting Your Asylum Application
AILA provides a flyer to inform your clients of ways to reduce the chance that their asylum case will be pretermitted. The flyer is available as a generic PDF version and a Word version you can customize with your firm's information.
CA9 Holds That Standalone Petition Challenging Only a CAT Order Does Not Establish Jurisdiction Under INA §242(a)(1)
The court held that a petition challenging only a CAT order, without seeking review of a final removal order, does not invoke jurisdiction under INA §242(a)(1) because a CAT order is not itself a final removal order and does not merge into one. (Navarrete v. Blanche, 3/23/26, amended 11/6/26)
Think Immigration: Could This Be Our Time?
In this blog post, Sarah Lachman describes her hopes for the incoming Congress to end inhumane enforcement, create an Article I immigration court, and pursue real reform, and the opportunities available to discuss and learn with colleagues at the upcoming AILA New York Symposium.
BIA Holds That Motion to Reopen Filed After Voluntary Departure Period Does Not Lift 10-Year Bar to Cancellation
The BIA held that violating a voluntary departure agreement bars certain immigration benefits for 10 years and that filing a motion to reopen to submit new evidence on a prior cancellation application does not remove those consequences. Matter of Ontiveros-Diaz, 30 I&N Dec. 222 (BIA 2026)
CA2 Holds That Clear-Error Review Governs Cancellation of Removal Hardship Determinations
The court held that Toalombo Yanez v. Bondi remains binding on clear-error review of cancellation hardship determinations and that Al Saidi v. Blanche’s suggestion that Urias-Orellana v. Bondi abrogated that standard was dicta. (Diaz v. Blanche, 11/5/26)
BIA Holds Finding of Likely Future Torture Was Speculative Where It Relied on General Country Conditions Evidence
The BIA held that the IJ’s finding of likely future torture was speculative where generalized country conditions evidence failed to establish a particularized risk or support the IJ’s finding that the respondent could not internally relocate. Matter of K–Y–V–R–, 30 I&N Dec. 203 (BIA 2026)
AILA ED Condemns Trump Administration’s Plans to Deport Afghan Immigrants Back to Danger
AILA ED Ben Johnson responded to reports that the Trump Administration plans to deport scores of Afghan immigrants to Pakistan where they are expected to then be sent back to danger in Afghanistan, stating that “America can enforce its immigration laws without abandoning our values.”
CA4 Holds That Previously Admitted Adjustment Applicants Must Prove Admissibility by a Preponderance of the Evidence
The court held that previously admitted noncitizens seeking adjustment of status in removal proceedings must prove admissibility by a preponderance of the evidence, not clearly and beyond doubt, and that Dakura v. Holder’s contrary statement was dicta. (Nivar Santana v. Blanche, 11/2/26)
BIA Holds It Generally Will Not Reopen Proceedings Sua Sponte for Arriving Aliens Seeking Adjustment Before USCIS
The BIA reaffirmed Matter of Yauri, holding that it generally will not exercise its discretion to reopen proceedings sua sponte for an arriving alien to pursue adjustment of status before USCIS. Matter of Pierre-Louis, 30 I&N Dec. 212 (BIA 2026)
AILA ED: Supreme Court Declines Case, Further Undermining Independence of Immigration Courts
AILA ED Ben Johnson responded to the U.S. Supreme Court’s declining to take up the case regarding immigration judges’ authority to administratively close cases, stating that the Trump Administration has “coopted the courts to advance its mass deportation campaign.”
Think Immigration: AILA Celebrates Pro Bono Week 2026!
As part of Pro Bono Week 2026, AILA celebrates our members’ dedication to clients and the power of service; in this blog post, two attorneys share how pro bono work fuels persistent advocacy, builds practical skills, and connects practitioners with a community of support.
BIA Holds That South Carolina Second-Degree Assault and Battery Categorically Constitutes a CIMT
The BIA held that a conviction for assault and battery in the second degree in South Carolina, which requires a reckless mental state and the actual or attempted infliction of “moderate bodily injury,” is categorically for a CIMT. Matter of Mercader, 30 I&N Dec. 185 (BIA 2026)
CA6 Holds That It Lacks Jurisdiction over Standalone Reasonable-Fear Challenge
The court held it lacked jurisdiction over a petition challenging only an IJ’s negative reasonable-fear determination and recognized that Riley v. Bondi abrogated precedent permitting standalone review of withholding and CAT rulings. (Castro-Fuentes v. Blanche, 10/27/26)
DOJ 60-Day Notice of Revision and Extension of Forms EOIR-42A and EOIR-42B
DOJ notice of revision of Forms EOIR-42A, Application for Cancellation of Removal for Certain Permanent Residents and EOIR-42B, Application for Cancellation of Removal and Adjustment of Status for Certain Nonpermanent Residents. Comments due 11/25/26. (91 FR 53897, 8/20/26; 91 FR 67334, 10/26/26)
BIA Reverses Credibility Finding and Holds DHS Established Reason to Believe Returning LPR Engaged in Drug Trafficking
The BIA reversed the IJ’s credibility finding and held that DHS proved by clear and convincing evidence the returning LPR engaged in illegal activity after departure and there was reason to believe she knowingly trafficked drugs. Matter of Ozuna Mendoza, 30 I&N Dec. 177 (BIA 2026)
CA10 Holds It Has Jurisdiction over Reinstatement Orders After Riley v. Bondi but Dismisses Petition as Untimely
The court held that reinstatement orders remain reviewable after Riley but dismissed the petition as untimely, assuming without deciding that equitable tolling was available and finding that no extraordinary circumstance prevented timely filing. (Vizguerra-Ramirez v. Blanche, 10/26/26)
CA5 Holds Petitioners Not Lawfully Admitted Are Not Entitled to Bond Hearing
The court held that noncitizens who have not been admitted into the U.S. are not entitled to any process beyond what is provided by statute. Accordingly, an unadmitted noncitizen has no statutory or constitutional right to a bond hearing. (Sosnava Rodriguez v. Vergara, 10/23/26)
CA9 Remands Denial of Relief Where IJ Misunderstood Bisexuality and Denied Opportunity to Corroborate
The court held that the agency misunderstood the petitioner’s particular social group based on his bisexual orientation and erred by failing to give petitioner notice and a meaningful opportunity to present additional corroborating evidence to support his claim. (A.M. v. Blanche, 10/23/26)
Think Immigration: An AILA Law Journal Issue for Our Times
AILA Law Journal Editor-in-Chief Cyrus Mehta describes the new edition, writing that the editorial board sought to “bring forward a collection of both original and thought-provoking articles by authors who have creatively advanced topics and ideas that may have received too little attention.”
BIA Holds That No Further Steps to Effect Notice Are Reasonably Available When Mail to Only Address of Record Is Undeliverable
The BIA held that when mail sent to a respondent’s only address of record is returned as undeliverable, there are no additional reasonably available or practicable steps the Board or an immigration court can take to effect notice. Matter of Chamorro Castillo, 30 I&N Dec. 170 (BIA 2026)
EOIR Announces Swearing in of 22 Immigration Judges and 4 Temporary Immigration Judges
EOIR announced the swearing in of 22 immigration judges and 4 temporary immigration judges. EOIR also provided biographical information for the new judges.
CA5 Finds Past Persecution Creates No Presumption of Future Torture and BIA May Screen New Evidence in Denying Remand
The court held that past persecution creates no presumption of future torture under the CAT, that substantial-evidence review governs CAT eligibility, and that the BIA may assess new evidence for reliability and probative value when deciding whether to remand. (Zahid v. Blanche, 10/20/26)
BIA Declines to Follow Ninth Circuit’s Inherently Unbelievable Standard for Affidavits Supporting Motion to Reopen
The BIA held that the Ninth Circuit’s inherently unbelievable standard conflicts with U.S. Supreme Court precedent, and that IJs and the BIA need not accept as true facts supporting a motion to reopen even if not inherently unbelievable. Matter of J–E–D–C–, 30 I&N Dec. 162 (BIA 2026)