Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0
The U.S. immigration court system plays a critical role in upholding due process and ensuring fair hearings for individuals facing deportation. However, since January 20, 2025, the Department of Justice (DOJ) has implemented significant changes that challenge the structural integrity of these courts. This page aims to provide up-to-date information on the policy and legal shifts affecting the U.S. immigration court system.
Latest Updates
Updates from EOIR
Browse the Featured Issue: U.S. Immigration Courts under Trump 2.0 collection
CA7 Says “Mexican Nationals Perceived as Wealthy After Returning from United States” Is Not a PSG
The court upheld the denial of withholding of removal to petitioner, finding that BIA properly found his proposed social group of “Mexican nationals who have lived in the U.S. for many years and are perceived as wealthy upon returning to Mexico” was not cognizable. (Salgado v. Lynch, 8/24/16)
AILA Notes from SCOPS Teleconference (8/24/16)
AILA notes from a teleconference with SCOPS on 8/24/16. Topics include I-612 waivers, asylee and refugee adjustment, hardship/persecution waivers for clinical physicians, signature requirements, cases at the Potomac Service Center, ELIS, and defensive asylum application receipts.
BIA Equitably Tolls Motion to Reopen Deadline To Submit Additional Evidence
Unpublished BIA decision reverses denial of motion to reopen, finding equitable tolling of deadline was warranted for submission of additional evidence outside of 90-day period. Special thanks to IRAC. (Matter of Dauphin, 8/24/16)
BIA Rescinds In Absentia Order In Light of Erroneous Denial of Motions to Appear Telephonically and Change Venue
Unpublished BIA decision rescinds in absentia order where DHS had not opposed motion to appear telephonically and IJ waited until day before hearing to deny motion to change venue. Special thanks to IRAC. (Matter of Galimidi, 8/24/16)
BIA Recognizes PSG of Honduran Women Unable to Leave Domestic Relationship
In this unpublished decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) held that “Honduran women unable to leave a domestic relationship” is a cognizable particular social group. Special thanks to IRAC. (Matter of I-M-E-G-, 8/23/16)
BIA Holds Virginia Unlawful Wounding Does Not Require Use of Force
Unpublished BIA decision finds hold unlawful wounding under Va. Code 18.2-51 not a crime of violence under 18 U.S.C. 16(a) because it applies to actions (e.g., poisoning) that do not require use of force. Special thanks to IRAC. (Matter of Lambert, 8/23/16)
CA1 Finds Threats Against Petitioner by His Father's Killer Were Motivated by Personal Dispute
The court upheld the denial of asylum and withholding of removal, finding that the threats made against the Guatemalan petitioner by his father’s killer were motivated not by an enumerated statutory ground for relief, but instead by a personal dispute. (Marín-Portillo v. Lynch, 8/23/16)
CA9 Remands Matter of Ortega-Lopez to Determine if Cockfighting Is a CIMT
The court remanded for the BIA to consider Nunez v. Holder’s language regarding a “protected class of victim” as it applies to the case, finding that petitioner’s conviction for cockfighting appears outside the normal realm of crimes of moral turpitude. (Ortega-Lopez v. Lynch, 8/23/16)
AILA Amicus Brief to BIA on Detention in the Context of Mental Health Commitment
The AILA Amicus Committee filed an amicus brief with the BIA, addressing the meanings of “detention” and “release” as they relate to mental health commitment.
CA5 Says INA §212(a)(7) Does Not Apply to Adjustment of Status Applicant Admitted as Nonimmigrant
The court granted the petition for review, holding that the documentation requirements of INA §212(a)(7) do not apply to an individual who was previously validly admitted as a nonimmigrant, is residing in the United States, and applies for adjustment of status. (Marques v. Lynch, 8/19/16)
CA9 Holds INA §242(b)(2)’s Venue Provision Is Not Jurisdictional
The court denied the government’s motion to transfer the case to the Eleventh Circuit, holding that the venue provision in INA §242(b)(2) is not jurisdictional, and thus that the petition for review properly fell under the Ninth Circuit’s judicial authority. (Bibiano v. Lynch, 8/19/16)
UNHCR Report: Beyond Detention (Baseline Report)
This is the first of two reports released on 08/18/16 related to UNHCR’s Beyond Detention Global Strategy. This Baseline Report provides data on the detention situation in 12 focus countries (including the United States) as of the end of 2013.
UNHCR Report: Beyond Detention (Progress Report Mid-2016)
This is the second of two reports released on 08/18/16 related to UNHCR’s Beyond Detention Global Strategy. This Progress Report reviews the first two years of the Global Strategy’s implementation and presents the progress achieved for 12 focus countries, including the United States.
AILA Urges DHS to Follow DOJ Lead and End Use of Private Prisons
In light of the Department of Justice’s announcement that it will sharply scale back the use of private prisons, AILA President Bill Stock urged the Department of Homeland Security to follow suit, saying “there is no justification for continuing their use in the immigration system.”
DOJ Memo: Reducing Our Use of Private Prisons
DOJ issued a memo to the Federal Bureau of Prisons calling for the reduction, and ultimately the ending, of the use of privately operated prisons and directing that as each contract ends, the Bureau should either decline to renew or substantially reduce the scope of the contract.
BIA Orders Further Consideration of Narcotics Trafficking Allegation
Unpublished BIA decision orders further consideration of inadmissibility under INA 212(a)(2)(C) of respondent given lack of evidence in record from criminal trial and failure of jury to convict over drug charges. Special thanks to IRAC. (Matter of Espinoza Leon, 8/17/16)
CA7 Upholds Withholding of Removal and CAT Denials to Bisexual Citizen of Jamaica
The court held that substantial evidence supported the IJ’s conclusion that the petitioner, a 51‐year‐old citizen of Jamaica who asserted a fear of persecution and torture in Jamaica based upon his claimed bisexuality, did not credibly establish that he is bisexual. (Fuller v. Lynch, 8/17/16)
TRAC Report on Percentage of Individuals in Immigration Court Allowed to Stay in U.S.
This TRAC report discusses the percentage of individuals against whom DHS sought removal orders who were determined to be allowed to remain in the U.S. by an immigration judge in FY2016. Statistics are provided for each of the 55 immigration courts.
CA5 Finds Petitioner Ineligible for Asylum Under Firm-Resettlement Bar
The court upheld the denial of asylum, finding that substantial evidence supported the BIA’s finding that the petitioner, a citizen of Bolivia who moved to Mexico in 2005, failed to establish the applicability of an exception to the firm-resettlement bar. (Ramos Lara v. Lynch, 8/17/16)
BIA Reverses IJ’s Denial of Asylum to Nigerian Woman Who Feared FGM
Unpublished BIA decision reversed the IJ’s factual findings of “implausibility” and adverse credibility against the Nigerian respondent, who feared that her husband would force her to undergo female genital mutilation in Nigeria. Courtesy of Eric Singer. (Matter of Chinyelu, 8/17/16)
ICE Policy Memo on Identifying and Monitoring Pregnant Detainees
ICE policy memo entitled “Identification and Monitoring of Pregnant Detainees” consolidating existing guidance and setting forth additional procedures to ensure that pregnant women detained in ICE custody are identified, monitored, and housed in the most appropriate facility to manage their care.
ICE Director Saldaña Response to Sign-On Letter on Immigration Raids
On 8/12/16, ICE Director Sarah Saldaña responded to a June 2016 sign-on letter to DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson and Attorney General Loretta Lynch on the aggressive tactics against Central Americans.
AILA Indiana Chapter Files Amicus Brief in Case Involving Undocumented Worker’s Injury
AILA’s Indiana Chapter submitted an amicus brief with the Supreme Court of Indiana, arguing that the Court of Appeals’ opinion creates an unworkable evidentiary standard based on a misunderstanding of immigration law. Courtesy of Thomas Ruge. (Escamilla v. Shiel Sexton Company, Inc., 8/12/16)
As Detained Mothers Continue Hunger Strike, AILA Urges Administration to End Family Detention
Twenty-two mothers being held with their children for months in the Berks family detention center began a hunger strike this week; AILA President William A. Stock urged an end to family detention, noting, “These brave mothers are putting their health at risk to draw attention to injustice.”
TRAC Report Questions Linkage Between Law Enforcement Cooperation and ICE’s Apprehension Numbers
This TRAC report, based upon a review of individual detainer records, calls into question the assumed linkage between cooperation with ICE by state and local law enforcement agencies and ICE’s success in apprehending immigrants it seeks to deport.