Featured Issues

Featured Issue: Representing Clients Before ICE

2/3/25 AILA Doc. No. 25010904. Removal & Relief

This resource page combines resources for attorneys representing clients before ICE. For information about why AILA is calling for the reduction and phasing out of immigration detention, please see our Featured Issue Page: Immigration Detention and Alternatives to Detention.

Quick Links

Communicating with OPLA, ERO, and CROs

The Office of the Principal Legal Advisor (OPLA) includes 1300 attorneys who represent the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in immigration removal proceedings before the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR). OPLA litigates all removal cases as well as provides legal counsel to ICE personnel. At present, there are 25 field locations throughout the United States.

Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) manages all aspects of immigration enforcement from arrest, detention, and removal. ERO has 24 field office locations. ERO also manages an “alternative to detention” program that relies almost exclusively on the “Intensive Supervision Appearance Program (ISAP)” to monitor individuals in removal proceedings.

Since 2016, ICE has had an Office of Partnership and Engagement (formerly Office of Community Engagement) to be a link between the agency and stakeholders. As part of this office, Community Relations Officers (CROS) are assigned to every field office to work with local stakeholders such as attorneys and nonprofit organizations.

*Headquarters does not provide direct contact numbers or emails for individual employees.* (AILA Liaison Meeting with ICE on April 26, 2023)(AILA Doc. No. 23033004). However, attorneys can contact Chapter Local ICE Liaisons as they may have this information provided to them via local liaison engagement.

Latest on Enforcement Priorities & Prosecutorial Discretion

Executive Order 14159 (90 FR 8443, 1/29/25) directs DHS to set priorities that protect the public safety and national security interests of the American people, including by ensuring the successful enforcement of final orders of removal, enforcement of the INA and other Federal laws related to the illegal entry and unlawful presence of [noncitizens] in the United States and the enforcement of the purposes of this order. Given the January 25, 2025, confirmation of DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, a memorandum detailing enforcement priorities may be issued in the coming weeks.

An unpublished ICE memo from acting ICE Director Caleb Vitello entitled “Interim Guidance: Civil Immigration Enforcement Actions in or near Courthouses” makes reference to targeted noncitizens and includes:

  • National security or public safety threats;
  • Those with criminal convictions;
  • Gang members;
  • Those who have been ordered removed from the United States but have failed to depart; and/or
  • Those who have re-entered the country illegally after being removed.

Procedures and email inboxes created under the Biden Administration to request Prosecutorial Discretion no longer appear on the ICE website. AILA members are encouraged to review current DOJ regulations entitled “Efficient Case and Docket Management in Immigration Proceedings” for alternative basis for seeking termination or administrative closure.

Access to Counsel

Filing Administrative Complaints on Behalf of Detained and Formerly Detained Clients

Selected ICE Policies and Current Status

For comprehensive comparison of current and prior ICE policies, please review the “Immigration Policy Tracker (IPTP).” The IPTP is a project of Professor Lucas Guttentag working with teams of Stanford and Yale law students and leading national immigration experts.

Pre Jan 20, 2025 Status Current Status
  • Unclear but attorneys should proceed with extreme caution in pursuing any relief under this process.
  • No recission has been announced.
  • No recission has been announced.
  • The 2021 Victim Centered Approach Memo and the 2011 Prosecutorial Discretion for Victims and Witness have allegedly been rescinded though no public updated guidance available at the time of this updated. Media reports suggest that the requirements of 1367 protections should still be followed.
  • No recission has been announced.
Browse the Featured Issue: Representing Clients Before ICE collection
9,551 - 9,575 of 13,034 collection items

Senators Ask for Executive Action on Behalf of DREAMers

A 4/13/11 letter from 22 Senators to President Obama asking that deferred action be granted to certain DREAM Act-eligible students.

AILA Public Statements, Memo & Regulatory Comments

AILA Comments on DHS Regulatory Review

AILA’s comments on the Department of Homeland Security’s implementation of Executive Order 13563, “Improving Regulation and Regulatory Review.” Special thanks to the AILA Interagency Liaison Committee.

Cases & Decisions, Amicus Briefs/Alerts

Spelling Out the Demise of DOMA in Five Steps

AILA Amicus Committee alert on what the 2/23/11 announcement by the DOJ means, where DOJ stated that it would no longer defend DOMA in pending litigation challenging its constitutionality but it would continue to enforce DOMA until there was a final judicial resolution.

4/12/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041259. Family Immigration, LGBTQ, Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

USCIS Asylum Division Stakeholder Meeting Minutes

USCIS Asylum Division minutes from its 4/12/11 quarterly stakeholder meeting. Topics include proposed customer inquiry response procedures, the asylum EAD Clock, and more. Original invitation follows minutes.

4/12/11 AILA Doc. No. 11030234. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

District Court Says Employee Has Right to Remain in U.S. While Extension Application Is Pending

The court held that ICE may not arrest an H-1B employee for whom a timely-filed extension application is pending and that “work authorization is part and parcel of their authorization to be in the country, not a separate matter.” (El Badrawi v. U.S., 4/11/11)

Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA9 Reverses Course on Acosta v. Gonzales

The court gave Chevron and Brand X deference to Matter of Briones, and held that aliens who are inadmissible under INA §212(a)(9)(C)(i)(I) may not seek adjustment of status under INA §245(i). (Garfias-Rodriguez v. Holder, 4/11/11)

4/11/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041260. Adjustment of Status, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Amicus Briefs/Alerts

Update on Padilla v. Kentucky in the State Courts: Analyzing Florida’s Hernandez v. State

AILA Amicus Committee alert on how Hernandez v. State characterized Padilla v. Kentucky as creating a “new rule” that should not be applied retroactively.

4/9/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040959. Crimes, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA9 Upholds Requirement that Past Persecution Occur in Country of Removal

The court upheld 8 CFR §1208.16(b)(1)(i), requiring past persecution to have occurred in the country of removal, and denied asylum to Petitioner who suffered spousal abuse only in the U.S. (Gonzalez-Medina v. Holder, 4/7/11)

4/7/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041161. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA9 Says BIA Has Jurisdiction to Review Post-Removal Motion

The court reaffirmed Coyt v. Holder and found that 8 CFR §1003.2(d) does not bar BIA jurisdiction to review a motion to reconsider and reopen filed after the petitioner has been involuntarily removed from the United States. (Reyes-Torres v. Holder, 4/7/11)

4/7/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041160. Cancellation, Suspension & 212(c), Removal & Relief
AILA Public Statements

AILA Denounces Deportations to Haiti as Life-Threatening

AILA's public statement calling on Obama Administration to suspend deportations to Haiti until life-threatening conditions in that country are resolved.

Federal Agencies, Liaison Minutes

AILA Liaison/USCIS Meetings Q&As (4/7/11)

Official Q&As from the 4/7/11 meeting between USCIS HQ and AILA liaison. USCIS responses address policy driving adjudications, Kazarian guidance, visa waiver program adjudications, H-1B portability, implementation of VIBE, and more.

Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA3 Finds Limited Jurisdiction over Decision to Deny Sua Sponte Reopening

The court found jurisdiction over the denial of a sua sponte motion and held that the BIA erred in finding that Petitioner’s health issues were irrelevant to his persecution claim. (Pllumi v. Att’y Gen. of the U.S., 4/6/11)

4/6/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040732. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

District Court Finds Padilla Cannot Be Applied Retroactively

The court held that generic warnings about the possibility of deportation are not sufficient to cure prejudice in a mandatory deportation case, but that Padilla cannot be applied retroactively in post-conviction proceedings. (Hernandez v. Florida, 4/6/11)

4/6/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040731. Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Liaison Minutes

AILA/EOIR Liaison Meeting Q&As (04/06/11)

Official questions and answers from an AILA EOIR Liaison Committee meeting with the EOIR on 4/6/11. Topics include the asylum EAD clock, gang-related asylum claims, Matter of R-A-, notice of hearings, limited appearances, joint motions, change of venue, and more.

4/6/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040810. Asylum & Refugees, Detention & Bond, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, DOJ/EOIR Cases

BIA Says IJ's Conclusions on Extrajudicial Killing Were Not Speculative

The BIA held that an IJ may make reasonable inferences from direct and circumstantial evidence, and is not required to accept respondent's account where other plausible views of the evidence are supported by the record. Matter of D-R-, 25 I&N Dec. 445 (BIA 2011)

4/6/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041466. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
AILA Public Statements, Correspondence

AILA/AIC Letter to Secretary Napolitano on DHS’ Use of Prosecutorial Discretion

AILA and AIC letter to DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano expressing concerns and offering assistance and perspective with respect to implementing a well-balanced policy on the exercise of prosecutorial discretion.

4/6/11 AILA Doc. No. 11041568. Prosecutorial Discretion, Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

ICE Announces Policy for Resumed Removals to Haiti

ICE press release announcing that the agency is resuming the limited removal of convicted criminal Haitians with final orders of removal. At this time, ICE is not removing non-criminal Haitian nationals unless they are determined to be a significant national security threat.

Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA9 on “Changed Circumstances” and the One-Year Asylum Deadline

“Changed circumstances” does not require an entirely new conflict in the applicant’s country of origin, nor does the law preclude an applicant who has always feared persecution from seeking asylum because the risk of persecution increases. (Vahora v. Holder, 4/5/11)

4/5/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040765. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA7 Says §212(h) Cannot Waive Conviction Barring Cancellation

For purposes of cancellation of removal, the court held that a conviction for possession of drug paraphernalia is an offense “relating to a controlled substance” under INA §212(a)(2), and that INA §212(h) cannot serve to waive the conviction. (Barma v. Holder, 4/5/11)

4/5/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040660. Cancellation, Suspension & 212(c), Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

ICE Memo on Strategic Use of Expedited Removal

ICE memo, dated 4/5/11, from Gary Mead, Executive Associate Director, on the strategic use of expedited removal authority. Also includes a list of instances that expedited removal should not be used. Obtained through FOIA by Stephen Yale-Loehr.

Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA5 Finds Administrative Voluntary Departure Interrupts Continuous Residence

The court held that Petitioner’s administrative voluntary departure interrupted his continuous residence such that he was never eligible for LPR status under IRCA, and is therefore now not eligible for LPR cancellation of removal. (Ramos-Torres v. Holder, 4/4/11)

4/4/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040560. Cancellation, Suspension & 212(c), Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

ICE Announces Sentencing in Scheme to Recruit Undocumented Workers

ICE press release announcing the owner of Lucky employment agency was sentenced to two years in prison, three years probation, and forfeiture of $5,200, for conspiring to transport and harbor undocumented workers. She is expected to be deported after completing her sentence.

4/4/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040472. Employer Compliance, Removal & Relief
Cases & Decisions, Federal Court Cases

CA9 Clarifies Standard for Stays of Removal in Light of Nken v. Holder

The court held that where the alien makes a threshold showing that irreparable harm is probable absent a stay, the court will then weigh the equities according to the general balancing approach set forth in Abassi v. INS. (Leiva-Perez v. Holder, 4/1/11)

4/1/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040465. Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

Immigration Law Advisor, March 2011 (Vol. 5, No. 3)

Immigration Law Advisor, a legal publication from EOIR, with an article on document similarities and credibility findings in immigration proceedings, circuit court decisions for February 2011, an article on the “exclusionary rule”, recent BIA precedent decisions, and a regulatory update.

4/1/11 AILA Doc. No. 11040199. Asylum & Refugees, Removal & Relief
Federal Agencies, Agency Memos & Announcements

DOJ OIL March 2011 Litigation Bulletin

DOJ Office of Immigration Litigation (OIL) March 2011 Litigation Bulletin covers the court’s holding that application of the 30-day deadline does not violate the Suspension Clause, motions to reopen alleging changed country conditions, summaries of court decisions, and more.